Wednesday season 2 ending theory: Is Barry Dort just a decoy? Fans speculate entry of a new principal at Nevermore in season 3

Wednesday Season 2 Part 1 ended with a bloody fall, a missing villain, and a school on the edge of chaos. But fans aren't just talking about the cliffhanger or Tyler's return as the Hyde. Many believe that Nevermore Academy will see a new principal in Season 3, and the speculation is growing louder online. While nothing is confirmed, clues from the show’s past and present, plus the teaser for Part 2, have convinced fans that the school’s leadership is about to change again, possibly for good.


The second season kicked off with new powers, more danger, and Wednesday seeing dark visions once again. The Addams family returned in full force. Pugsley’s electric abilities were revealed, and Uncle Fester played a key role. But things quickly went off the rails. A mysterious murder took place. Tyler, the Hyde, escaped from captivity. And in the final moments of Episode 4, Wednesday was thrown out of a window, bloodied and unconscious, while Tyler disappeared into the forest.

Wednesday also lost her powers this season. After seeing a vision of Enid’s death, her psychic abilities faded, leaving her vulnerable and confused. The season left that thread hanging, too, no answers, only questions.


After Larissa Weems died at the end of Season 1, Nevermore got a new principal in Barry Dort (played by Steve Buscemi). But fans aren't convinced he'll stick around.

One theory on Reddit says, “Weems was clearly gonna die. The current principal is an antagonist, so he’s not gonna stick around for long. We’ll almost certainly get a new principal come next season.”


Another user believes he’s a decoy villain: “I think he’s the cop-out antagonist who hides the real one of the season, but I think he’s still going to die.”


These theories have gained traction because Dort hasn’t built real trust with viewers or students at Nevermore. His shady behaviour, odd decisions, and tense dynamic with Wednesday make fans feel like his time is limited. Plus, if Tyler returns to wreak havoc again, Nevermore will need stronger leadership or someone darker.


Season 2, Part 2’s teaser shows a chained Tyler in Willow Hill hospital. But he’s no longer just a teen hiding a secret. He’s dangerous, unhinged, and planning something. Many think he’ll rise as the show’s big villain again.

Some fans still believe in a possible redemption: “Wouldn’t be surprised if they tried to redeem Tyler, maybe even give him a twist like saving Wednesday.” But others see no way back: “He literally killed people. Redemption shouldn’t be on the table. He’ll be the main villain again.”


The teaser shows him face-to-face with Wednesday, and it’s intense. His future could go either way, but one thing’s certain: his presence will shake Nevermore again.


Part 2 of Wednesday Season 2 is set to return on September 3, 2025, with even more mystery and supernatural drama. Fans are expecting big answers, especially around Wednesday’s powers, Tyler’s fate, and what’s happening at Nevermore Academy. Whether the school gets a new principal or not, one thing is clear: something is brewing behind those gothic walls.




No official confirmation yet, but fan theories strongly suggest a new face is coming.


Possibly in Part 2, though it’s unclear how. Trauma from her fall might trigger them.


Most likely, though some fans think there might be a twist or a redemption arc.


Wednesday season 2, part 2, releases on September 3, 2025, exclusively on Netflix.